In Minds in Ablation Sean Mewhinney summarizes why he believes the physical evidence provided by paleoclimatic data, especially ice cores, demonstrates that global catastrophes of the type envisioned by Immanuel Velikovsky and others "could not have happened within the past many thousands of years," and refutes the defense of Velikovsky's scenario attempted by Charles Ginenthal in his Ice Core Evidence. You will find Ginenthal's reply to parts one through five of Minds in Ablation at Minds in Denial.
Back to my criticisms of catastrophism page.
Back to my catastrophism page.
Back to my interests.
Back to my home page.
Search my pages.
Last modified by pib on October 28, 2003.